The primary fieldwork site was at one of the original schools in the competition, Mangere College, as they prepared for the ASB Polyfest from February to early March over two school years. Students, teachers, cultural group tutors, competition judges and stage directors were all generous collaborators through interviews and focus groups.
My methodology was supported by ethnomusicology and Pacific research models, which converged on three main values: relationships, collaboration and reciprocity.
Relationships in Fieldwork Research
Relationships have specific characteristics in a Pacific context (Vaioleti, 2003) and many Pacific cultures view relationships in the context of ‘va’. Wendt (1996) defines va as “the space between…not empty space, not space that separates but space that relates…the space giving meaning to things. The meanings change as the relationships/the contexts change.” Tamasese et al (2005) assert that the Samoan sense of self is a relational one, with the self “having meaning only in relationships with other people, not as an individual” (p. 303). The self is sacred in nature, and is not separable from the va or “relational space” between an individual and their family and community (Tamasese et al, 2005). As relationships between people change depending on context, the va should be nurtured to accommodate this fluidity (Taufe’ulungaki, 2004). Mila-Schaaf (2010) suggests that va is congruous with harmonious, balanced relationships. Anae (2010) argues that, in the research process,
individual agendas should be transformed into relational contexts between people, things and environment in the nurturing and protection of mutually respectful relationships, for the good of what is at stake...This means that working together involves attaining balance and harmony in all human interconnections and relationships — in expectations, behaviours, and communication. (p. 39).
Anae (2007) constructs her recommendations for best practice in Pacific research based upon the Samoan philosophical reference point teu le va, which translates approximately as “take care of the relationship” (p.18)
The “new fieldwork” in ethnomusicology is one that is rooted in relationships and shared experiences (Barz & Cooley 2008; Kisliuk, 2008; Rice, 2008; Beaudry, 2008). According to Titon, fieldwork
is no longer viewed principally as observing and collecting…but as experiencing and understanding music. The new fieldwork leads us to ask what it is like for a person (ourselves included) to make and to know music as lived experience (2008, p. 25).
Barz and Cooley (2008) use the metaphor of shadows to suggest how the ethnographer's own histories cross those belonging to research participants and to the field itself. According to Titon, fieldwork is “intersubjective and personally transformative” (2008, p.18) and “what we can know arises out of our relations with others” (p. 38). Titon describes how the affiliation between participant and researcher in ethnomusicology can be one of an implied but unspoken reciprocal agreement, a hierarchal relationship of master and apprentice, or a “combination of friendship and tacit contract” (p. 33). The positioning of researcher and participants in ethnographic research often operates along a continuum of various forms of friendship. Researchers have written about the role of friendship in ethnographic fieldwork and both the rewards and complexities it can bring to the research process (Devarajan, 2010; Barz and Cooley 2008). Devarajan (2010) argues,
Friendship provides something of a revolving door in and out of a glass-walled world of practitioners. The ethnographer can experience this world from the inside, entering the glass-walled world as a fellow practitioner and friend, but also exiting through the same revolving door to present these experiences to the outside (p. 78).
However, the subsequent responsibilities to participants who become friends become, as Devarajan explains, “more than just reciprocity” (2010, p.74) as researchers have to temper their guardianship of participants' mores and beliefs with providing an account of their views and experiences. In order to remain within the parameters of friendship, the researcher may have to self-censure; however, Devarajan maintains that the ethnographic process and the connection between academia and local communities are strengthened by the experience of friendship in fieldwork (2010).
An increasingly significant variable in ethnographic research is the nature of friendship and social media, which has established new parameters and characteristics of both offline and online relationships (Bryant & Marmo 2012; Lee 2013; Lemieux 2011). Friendships sustained by social networking sites, such as Facebook, do not require the consistent offline contact that defines traditional friendship. Facebook interactions are also governed by certain rules, particularly casual friends and acquaintances, with whom interaction may take place primarily through the site (Bryant & Marmo 2012). Arguably researchers can easily fall into one of these categories, particularly when fieldwork is completed. Privacy is also willingly compromised by Facebook users in exchange for being connected (Lee 2013) and many young users are willing to be friends with someone they don't know well (Lemieux 2011). Facebook friendships are also dependent on the 'frictionless sharing' of the News Feed, where life events are publicly shared by users and viewed passively by their friends (Lee 2013).
Collaboration and Reciprocity
Tongan scholar Konai Helu Thaman developed the Kakala (garland) framework, based on both Pacific and Western epistemologies (Thaman, 2016). Kakala reflects the three stages of research (data collection, data analysis and dissemination of results) as components of weaving a flower garland. Toli is the collection of flowers and leaves, informed by experience and knowledge to select and rank the appropriate materials at the correct time and place. Tui is the knowledgeable construction of the kakala, to prepare it for luva, the giving away of the kakala, representing 'ofa (compassion) and faka'apa'apa (respect). Kakala is useful for its emphasis on reciprocity with Pacific communities (Tunufa'i, 2016) and “ensures cultural inclusivity and ownership” (Thaman, 2006, p. 182). It is also well-suited to ethnomusicology because of the personal nature of musical knowledge and traditions and the growing interest toward applied outcomes which reciprocate research participants (Titon 2008; Seeger 2008). As Titon (2008) posits, fieldwork should be “ongoing dialogue” which “continually reworks my ‘work’ as ‘our’ work” (p.32).
Talanoa, an existing practice of oratory in multiple Pacific cultures, (Fa'avae, Jones and Manu'atu 2016) has been developed as a research approach primarily by Tongan scholar Timote Vaioleti (2003) and since its publication, has been applied frequently by both Pacific and non-Pacific researchers (Tunufa'i, 2016). According to Vaioleti (2003), Talanoa is a departure from Western institutional methods based in objectivity and hypotheses, and in contrast, is “subjective, mostly oral and collaborative, and is resistant to rigid institutional hegemonic control” (p. 16). During the type of talanoa that most resembles an interview, talanoa faka’eke’eke (Vaioleti, 2014) the researcher does not approach the conversation with a set list of questions. Therefore, participants are granted greater agency to define the issues discussed, and divulge information in a chosen time and context. Vaioleti posits that “Talanoa removes the distance between researcher and participant, and provides the participants with a human face they can relate to” (2003, p. 18). During Talanoa,
an open technique is employed, where the precise nature of questions has not been determined in advance, but will depend on the way in which the talanoa develops (similar to snowballing). It is a respectful reciprocating interaction. Talanoa is a good conversation; one listens to the other. When to speak, and what one says, depends on what the other has to say (Vaioleti, 2003, p.18).
Researchers should be observant, show appreciation of the participant’s contributions, help the participant if there is a need, and not dominate the conversation or flaunt their knowledge. Vaioleti (2003) posits that the process of Talanoa makes researcher and participant more accountable to one another and more invested in the research.
Talanoa shares similarities with what Titon (2008) calls “visiting” (p. 38) in ethnomusicology fieldwork. There are foundations of a relationship established before the participant is expected to aid with research, and participants are treated with a “special kind of courtesy.” He explains, “Visiting means treating others with respect, care, modesty, courtesy, exchange, and reciprocity. It means establishing a sound and hopeful relationship before 'getting down to purpose,' if there is any purpose to get down to” (p. 38).
Narratives and Identity Stories
As discussed earlier, the concept of researching “Pacific” people as a group has problematic aspects. Much “Pacific” research in New Zealand has lacked identification of specific population cohorts in favor of generic pan-Pacific/Polynesian groups (Anae, 2007). Anae identifies the “need to expose and understand the nuances of self-perceived ethnic identity” through qualitative and ethnographic methods (2007, p. 17). The individuality of identity stories, according to Fairbairn-Dunlop and Makisi (2003) “provide insight into the complex process of identity formation in a country where [Pacific] identity has until recently been defined by others” (p. 11)…Despite the commonalities, each is an individual journey” (p. 12). Mila-Schaaf's use of identity stories in her study of second-gen[eration] Pacific peoples added complexity and at times refuted “the accepted canon of public narrative about Pasifika or New Zealand identities” (2010, p. 59).
Individual stories, as “ethnographies of the particular,” work against essentialised notions of culture (Abu-Lughod, 1996, p. 473). Writing about the actions and experiences of individuals “show[s] that although the terms of their discourses may be set (and, as in any society, include several sometimes contradictory and often historically changing discourses), within these limits, people contest interpretations of what is happening, strategize, feel pain, and live their lives” (Abu-Lughod, 1996, p. 474). In Pacific research, researchers should work to “ensure that diverse Pacific peoples’ own narratives gain traction become the dominant discourse, because in turn this determines possibilities for Pacific ‘ownership’” of applied research outcomes (Airini et al 2010, p. 14).
Focus groups and participant observation
My methodology was supported by ethnomusicology and Pacific research models, which converged on three main values: relationships, collaboration and reciprocity.
Relationships in Fieldwork Research
Relationships have specific characteristics in a Pacific context (Vaioleti, 2003) and many Pacific cultures view relationships in the context of ‘va’. Wendt (1996) defines va as “the space between…not empty space, not space that separates but space that relates…the space giving meaning to things. The meanings change as the relationships/the contexts change.” Tamasese et al (2005) assert that the Samoan sense of self is a relational one, with the self “having meaning only in relationships with other people, not as an individual” (p. 303). The self is sacred in nature, and is not separable from the va or “relational space” between an individual and their family and community (Tamasese et al, 2005). As relationships between people change depending on context, the va should be nurtured to accommodate this fluidity (Taufe’ulungaki, 2004). Mila-Schaaf (2010) suggests that va is congruous with harmonious, balanced relationships. Anae (2010) argues that, in the research process,
individual agendas should be transformed into relational contexts between people, things and environment in the nurturing and protection of mutually respectful relationships, for the good of what is at stake...This means that working together involves attaining balance and harmony in all human interconnections and relationships — in expectations, behaviours, and communication. (p. 39).
Anae (2007) constructs her recommendations for best practice in Pacific research based upon the Samoan philosophical reference point teu le va, which translates approximately as “take care of the relationship” (p.18)
The “new fieldwork” in ethnomusicology is one that is rooted in relationships and shared experiences (Barz & Cooley 2008; Kisliuk, 2008; Rice, 2008; Beaudry, 2008). According to Titon, fieldwork
is no longer viewed principally as observing and collecting…but as experiencing and understanding music. The new fieldwork leads us to ask what it is like for a person (ourselves included) to make and to know music as lived experience (2008, p. 25).
Barz and Cooley (2008) use the metaphor of shadows to suggest how the ethnographer's own histories cross those belonging to research participants and to the field itself. According to Titon, fieldwork is “intersubjective and personally transformative” (2008, p.18) and “what we can know arises out of our relations with others” (p. 38). Titon describes how the affiliation between participant and researcher in ethnomusicology can be one of an implied but unspoken reciprocal agreement, a hierarchal relationship of master and apprentice, or a “combination of friendship and tacit contract” (p. 33). The positioning of researcher and participants in ethnographic research often operates along a continuum of various forms of friendship. Researchers have written about the role of friendship in ethnographic fieldwork and both the rewards and complexities it can bring to the research process (Devarajan, 2010; Barz and Cooley 2008). Devarajan (2010) argues,
Friendship provides something of a revolving door in and out of a glass-walled world of practitioners. The ethnographer can experience this world from the inside, entering the glass-walled world as a fellow practitioner and friend, but also exiting through the same revolving door to present these experiences to the outside (p. 78).
However, the subsequent responsibilities to participants who become friends become, as Devarajan explains, “more than just reciprocity” (2010, p.74) as researchers have to temper their guardianship of participants' mores and beliefs with providing an account of their views and experiences. In order to remain within the parameters of friendship, the researcher may have to self-censure; however, Devarajan maintains that the ethnographic process and the connection between academia and local communities are strengthened by the experience of friendship in fieldwork (2010).
An increasingly significant variable in ethnographic research is the nature of friendship and social media, which has established new parameters and characteristics of both offline and online relationships (Bryant & Marmo 2012; Lee 2013; Lemieux 2011). Friendships sustained by social networking sites, such as Facebook, do not require the consistent offline contact that defines traditional friendship. Facebook interactions are also governed by certain rules, particularly casual friends and acquaintances, with whom interaction may take place primarily through the site (Bryant & Marmo 2012). Arguably researchers can easily fall into one of these categories, particularly when fieldwork is completed. Privacy is also willingly compromised by Facebook users in exchange for being connected (Lee 2013) and many young users are willing to be friends with someone they don't know well (Lemieux 2011). Facebook friendships are also dependent on the 'frictionless sharing' of the News Feed, where life events are publicly shared by users and viewed passively by their friends (Lee 2013).
Collaboration and Reciprocity
Tongan scholar Konai Helu Thaman developed the Kakala (garland) framework, based on both Pacific and Western epistemologies (Thaman, 2016). Kakala reflects the three stages of research (data collection, data analysis and dissemination of results) as components of weaving a flower garland. Toli is the collection of flowers and leaves, informed by experience and knowledge to select and rank the appropriate materials at the correct time and place. Tui is the knowledgeable construction of the kakala, to prepare it for luva, the giving away of the kakala, representing 'ofa (compassion) and faka'apa'apa (respect). Kakala is useful for its emphasis on reciprocity with Pacific communities (Tunufa'i, 2016) and “ensures cultural inclusivity and ownership” (Thaman, 2006, p. 182). It is also well-suited to ethnomusicology because of the personal nature of musical knowledge and traditions and the growing interest toward applied outcomes which reciprocate research participants (Titon 2008; Seeger 2008). As Titon (2008) posits, fieldwork should be “ongoing dialogue” which “continually reworks my ‘work’ as ‘our’ work” (p.32).
Talanoa, an existing practice of oratory in multiple Pacific cultures, (Fa'avae, Jones and Manu'atu 2016) has been developed as a research approach primarily by Tongan scholar Timote Vaioleti (2003) and since its publication, has been applied frequently by both Pacific and non-Pacific researchers (Tunufa'i, 2016). According to Vaioleti (2003), Talanoa is a departure from Western institutional methods based in objectivity and hypotheses, and in contrast, is “subjective, mostly oral and collaborative, and is resistant to rigid institutional hegemonic control” (p. 16). During the type of talanoa that most resembles an interview, talanoa faka’eke’eke (Vaioleti, 2014) the researcher does not approach the conversation with a set list of questions. Therefore, participants are granted greater agency to define the issues discussed, and divulge information in a chosen time and context. Vaioleti posits that “Talanoa removes the distance between researcher and participant, and provides the participants with a human face they can relate to” (2003, p. 18). During Talanoa,
an open technique is employed, where the precise nature of questions has not been determined in advance, but will depend on the way in which the talanoa develops (similar to snowballing). It is a respectful reciprocating interaction. Talanoa is a good conversation; one listens to the other. When to speak, and what one says, depends on what the other has to say (Vaioleti, 2003, p.18).
Researchers should be observant, show appreciation of the participant’s contributions, help the participant if there is a need, and not dominate the conversation or flaunt their knowledge. Vaioleti (2003) posits that the process of Talanoa makes researcher and participant more accountable to one another and more invested in the research.
Talanoa shares similarities with what Titon (2008) calls “visiting” (p. 38) in ethnomusicology fieldwork. There are foundations of a relationship established before the participant is expected to aid with research, and participants are treated with a “special kind of courtesy.” He explains, “Visiting means treating others with respect, care, modesty, courtesy, exchange, and reciprocity. It means establishing a sound and hopeful relationship before 'getting down to purpose,' if there is any purpose to get down to” (p. 38).
Narratives and Identity Stories
As discussed earlier, the concept of researching “Pacific” people as a group has problematic aspects. Much “Pacific” research in New Zealand has lacked identification of specific population cohorts in favor of generic pan-Pacific/Polynesian groups (Anae, 2007). Anae identifies the “need to expose and understand the nuances of self-perceived ethnic identity” through qualitative and ethnographic methods (2007, p. 17). The individuality of identity stories, according to Fairbairn-Dunlop and Makisi (2003) “provide insight into the complex process of identity formation in a country where [Pacific] identity has until recently been defined by others” (p. 11)…Despite the commonalities, each is an individual journey” (p. 12). Mila-Schaaf's use of identity stories in her study of second-gen[eration] Pacific peoples added complexity and at times refuted “the accepted canon of public narrative about Pasifika or New Zealand identities” (2010, p. 59).
Individual stories, as “ethnographies of the particular,” work against essentialised notions of culture (Abu-Lughod, 1996, p. 473). Writing about the actions and experiences of individuals “show[s] that although the terms of their discourses may be set (and, as in any society, include several sometimes contradictory and often historically changing discourses), within these limits, people contest interpretations of what is happening, strategize, feel pain, and live their lives” (Abu-Lughod, 1996, p. 474). In Pacific research, researchers should work to “ensure that diverse Pacific peoples’ own narratives gain traction become the dominant discourse, because in turn this determines possibilities for Pacific ‘ownership’” of applied research outcomes (Airini et al 2010, p. 14).
Focus groups and participant observation